Integrated Crop Management

Getting the most from nitrogen fertilizer dollars

For some producers, high fertilizer nitrogen (N) prices will add significant costs to corn production this year. What management options can producers take to get the most return from added N?

Where to apply N and at what rate? Allocate more N to where it is needed most. If your N costs are high, or products are in short supply, then allocate more N to the situations with greatest potential response to applied N. This allocation would be to the most responsive crops and rotations. Table 1 gives recommended preplant corn N rates for various rotations. Also closely evaluate the rate required in each rotation for your soils and geographic location. If you have been applying N at rates above the ranges suggested in Table 1, reduce them into the suggested range. If you are already within the range and have not observed N deficiencies in the past, consider decreasing rates to the lower part of the range. Research conducted in Iowa often indicate that N rates in the lower part of the ranges are adequate.

Because corn is so responsive to N and because the largest return occurs to the first increments of applied N, if fertilizer N supply is short it is probably better to apply a lower rate of N to all corn acres than to skip fields. Exceptions are 1) fields with adequate rates of manure, 2) first-year corn after alfalfa, and 3) fields receiving adequate rates of other forms of N such as by-products or biosolids. Because corn rotated with other crops requires less N and returns higher yields than continuous corn, consider rotating corn after soybean or after alfalfa instead of planting corn after corn. An example of a long-term rotation study from the Iowa State University Northeast Research and Demonstration Farm is shown in Table 2. Decisions to change rotation should be weighed carefully. Not growing corn and instead planting soybean after soybean, for instance, can lead to lower soybean yield and increased potential for disease and nematode problems.

With increased N prices, it would be justified to reduce rates somewhat. However, when fields are very responsive to applied N, reductions should not be dramatic and in general perhaps not more than 10 to 20 percent less. Remember, greatest yield increase comes from the first units of applied N, and least from the last. Looking at the yields in Table 2 for the corn-soybean (C-S) rotation, the first 80 lb N returned 42 bu corn/acre ($98.70/acre at $2.35/bu corn at a fertilizer cost of $16.00/acre at $0.20/lb N). The second 80 lb N returned 9 bu/acre ($21.15/acre at a cost of $16.00/acre). The last 80 lb N returned only 4 bu/acre ($9.40/acre at a cost of $16.00/acre, a losing application). Using an average response from 72 site-years where corn followed soybean across Iowa the past 24 years (data from research farm and on-farm trials, Figure 1), produces an economic N rate of 127 lb N/acre at 161 bu/acre (using a corn:N price ratio of 10:1, $2.00/bu corn and $0.20/lb N). Increasing or decreasing prices results in an associated change in economic N rate, and yield increase or decrease (Table 3). The corn response may justify economic application of high-cost N, but there will be both lowered productivity and increased N cost, thus lower return.

72 Site-Years in Iowa; Corn-Soybean Rotation

What N is being applied?

Take into account all N being applied to cornfields. Nitrogen recommendations are for the total amount of N needed. Therefore, add up the N coming from various fertilizers such as diammonium phosphate (DAP), weed and feed urea-ammonium nitrate (UAN), and starters. These amounts should then be subtracted from recommendations such as those shown in Table 1.

What are alternative N sources?

Use alternative N sources such as manure, biosolids, and N-containing by-products (such as liquid ammonium sulfate). Closely measure the nutrient content of animal manure and carefully apply agronomic rates.

How can productivity be improved?

Adopt proven crop management practices: soil conservation; IPM; adapted high-yielding hybrids; crop rotations; and optimal soil pH, phosphorus, and potassium levels. These practices help to ensure optimal N use efficiency.

How well is N applied?

Calibrate applicators, apply fertilizer products and manure accurately, and use the correct method and placement to avoid losses.

In summary, applying these management options can help increase returns from dollars spent on N. Increased fertilizer costs will detract from overall profitability, but carefully assessing needs and application options will help minimize expenses and increase overall return on fertilizer N investments.

Table 1. Recommended N rates for corn production based on crop rotation.

Rotation Nitrogen Rate, lb N/acre
Corn after established alfalfa 0-30
Second-year corn after alfalfa 0-60
Corn after corn 150-200
Corn after soybean 100-150

Adapted from Table 1 of Iowa State University publication PM 1714, Nitrogen Fertilizer Recommendations for Corn in Iowa.

Table 2. Effect of crop rotation on average yield and response to applied N for the 23-year period of 1979 to 2001, Northeast Research and Demonstration Farm, Nashua, IA.

N Rate (lb N/acre to corn only)a
0 80 160 240
Rotation Crop bu/acre for corn and soybean
C-C Corn 54 106 129 137
C-S Corn 100 142 151 155
Soybean 44.7 45.9 45.4 44.7
C-C-S Corn (first) 100 139 152 153
Corn (second) 54 106 129 137
Soybean 48.3 47.6 48.3 48.1
C-C-C-S Corn (first) 99 136 149 151
Corn (second) 56 106 131 138
Corn (third) 56 102 127 136
Soybean 50.3 49.7 49.8 49.2
S-S Soybean 37.5 38.0 39.3 38.5

C, corn; S, soybean.

a The nitrogen source is spring incorporated urea.

Adapted from Effects of crop rotation and nitrogen fertilization on crop production, by Antonio Mallarino and Ken Pecinovsky. pp. 24-25. Northeast Research and Demonstration Farm report, ISRF01-13.

Table 3. Effect of corn and N price on economic N rate and corn yield, corn-soybean rotation. Data developed from yield response shown in Figure 1.

Corn

Price

$/bu
Nitrogen Price, $/lb N
$0.10 $0.15 $0.20 $0.25 $0.30 $0.35 $0.40 $0.45
Economic N Rate, lb N/acre
$1.50 135 127 119 111 103 95 87 79
$1.75 137 130 124 117 110 103 96 89
$2.00 139 133 127 121 115 109 103 97
$2.25 140 135 130 124 119 114 108 103
$2.50 141 137 132 127 122 117 113 108
$2.75 142 138 134 129 125 120 116 112
$3.00 143 139 135 131 127 123 119 115
 
Corn

Price

$/bu
Nitrogen Price, $/lb N
$0.10 $0.15 $0.20 $0.25 $0.30 $0.35 $0.40 $0.45
Corn Yield at Economic N Rate, bu/acre
$1.50 161.9 161.2 160.3 159.1 157.6 155.8 153.8 151.6
$1.75 162.0 161.5 160.8 159.9 158.9 157.6 156.1 154.4
$2.00 162.1 161.7 161.2 160.5 159.7 158.7 157.6 156.3
$2.25 162.2 161.9 161.4 160.9 160.3 159.5 158.6 157.6
$2.50 162.2 162.0 161.6 161.2 160.7 160.0 159.3 158.5
$2.75 162.2 162.0 161.8 161.4 161.0 160.4 159.9 159.2
$3.00 162.3 162.1 161.9 161.6 161.2 160.8 160.3 159.7

This article originally appeared on pages 29-31 of the IC-490 (4) -- April 14, 2003 issue.


Source URL:
http://www.ipm.iastate.edu/ipm/icm//ipm/icm/2003/4-14-2003/nfert.html